CORNWALL Council has rejected plans to build three eco holiday lodges on the edge of Calstock, after concluding the development would harm the protected Tamar Valley landscape.
The outline application sought permission, with all matters reserved, for three tourist accommodation units on land west of Harewood Vineyard, off Eric Road.
The proposal attracted a mixed response, with numerous objections from residents, while others supported the scheme. Indeed, Calstock Parish Council initially backed the application, although it later changed its position and supported the planning officer’s recommendation for refusal.
In its decision, the council said the lodges would introduce an unacceptable amount of built development into the rural edge of Calstock and erode the transition between the village and surrounding countryside.
It also concluded the units would be highly visible within the Tamar Valley National Landscape and would fail to conserve or enhance the protected area.
The refusal notice said the development would be “incongruous and inharmonious”, causing harm to the landscape and scenic beauty which was not outweighed by any public benefit.
The application was submitted by Mr J Woodley and received by the council on April 27.
The applicant had argued the site was enclosed by trees, buildings and mature landscaping, meaning views were limited. The planning statement said the land was previously developed, with remnants of former structures still present, and that the lodges could be designed sensitively to sit within the landscape.
It also pointed to positive feedback received during pre-application discussions with Cornwall Council in January 2025. At that stage, the authority had indicated that the principle of three units of tourist accommodation could be acceptable, subject to matters including scale, design and accessibility.
The applicant also argued the proposal would provide a small-scale, sustainable tourism facility, with Calstock village, a bus stop and railway station all within walking distance.
However, Cornwall National Landscape objected to the plans, warning that the lodges, parking and associated facilities would have a negative impact on the character and appearance of the landscape.
Its response said the illustrative designs showed box-shaped units with projecting balconies which did not reflect local building styles. It also raised concerns about large, glazed areas, external lighting and potential effects on biodiversity.
The landscape body said the site formed part of Calstock’s rural backdrop and was visible from the Tamar Valley Discovery Trail, the Coast to Coast Way and public rights of way south of the river.
The parish council initially supported the proposal in May, while expressing concern about access along the narrow road and the indicative designs. After the National Landscape objection was received, it reconsidered its position.
In a later response on June 25, the parish council said it agreed with the planning officer’s recommendation to refuse the application, citing concerns about access and visual impact.
Find out about planning applications that affect you by visiting the Public Notice Portal.
The applicant had challenged the landscape assessment, arguing the site was not prominent, and that detailed design, landscaping and lighting could be controlled at a later stage. However, Cornwall Council concluded that the harm to the National Landscape was decisive and refused permission.






Comments
We've recently changed our login process. If you have an account for commenting, you will need to re-register on the login window.
This article has no comments yet. Be the first to leave a comment.